Question Home

Position:Home>Performing Arts> Please be inspired to comment on this amazing

Question: Please be inspired to comment on this amazing music!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!…
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=x5Swa9CYg!.!.!.

Please tell me what you think of this music video!

It's a singer/songwriter called Justin Vernon and his band is Bon Iver and the song is For Emma, forever gone!. I think it is brilliant and Beautiful but would love to know what other people think!.

P!.S!. it's on for 8 Min's but definitely worth watching until the end!.

Thanks in advance, ENJOY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Here's the rub!. The music is very pretty and very beautiful in places, but the execution was either very sloppy, wasn't consistently harmonized, was out of tune, or just wasn't *tight*!

But for all its flaws, I really like it!. It is beautiful!. I'm still not sold on brilliant, but I'm going to go pick up the album and think about it some more!.

I was writing this response the first time through and I was trying to find where it was that really rubbed me the wrong way when all of a sudden I realized that I loved the bloody song, and had to rewrite my original, scathing reply!.

How dare you expose me to new music that I actually like! Especially after I've decided I hate it! It's my weakness!.!.!. voices in harmony!.!.!. even slightly out of tune and not quite in sync!.!.!. can't help it!.!.!. can't resist!.!.!.!.!.


SaulWww@QuestionHome@Com

Could not STAND it to sit thru to the end - skipped around!. These guys CANNOT sing in tune - not even the unisons!. I have taught vocal music and managed various a capella groups for many years - these guys are nothing at all special!. You want to hear GOOD a capella singing!? Go to www!.acapella!.com and listen to ANYBODY on those clips!.

I get the feeling that this might be YOUR group and your are just fishing for compliments!. None here - and this is not my personal opinion, it is my 37-years in the business 3 degrees PROFESSIONAL opinion!. QUICK - I gotta listen to some Take 6 to wash out my ears!Www@QuestionHome@Com